PLEASE NOTE: Our phone numbers have changed.  You can find our updated contact details on our Contact Us page.

Located at 16050 McConnelsville Road in Caldwell, Ohio, Patrons Buckeye Mutual Insurance Company is a Mutual Insurance Company, established in March of 1896 for the purpose of providing insurance coverage to rural Ohio.  They offer a product to meet your insurance need whether it is for a farm, rental dwelling, home in town, secondary or seasonal dwelling, churches or mobile home.  They partner with Grinnell Mutual Insurance Company from Iowa to offer liability coverage to package with their Patrons Buckeye Mutual Policy.  Katherine Johnson is the Manager. The number is 740-305-5121

Emergency Phone Numbers

1-740-838-7191 ¤ 1-740-260-1088